why is zeno's paradox false

If an ancient Greek philosopher can describe a simple situation, which our intuition tells us is obviously correct, it's easy for us to assign it more significance than … In this paradox, Zeno argues that an arrow in flight is always at rest. is a valid extension of Zeno's paradox. However, the conclusion states that the runner cannot get anywhere. It is possible to iterate this to infinity. It's only a paradox if you assume that the sum of (countable) infinitely many numbers cannot be finite. What exactly is the paradox in Zeno's paradox? f:[0,\frac12] \longrightarrow [0,1] It only takes a minute to sign up. if Zeno's Paradox was an axiom-instead of a paradox-you would never have finished compiling this question. Is it possible to get the SHO approximation of a pendulum without using energy conservation? Zeno of Elia (a Greek philosopher in the 400s BCE) posed stark thought experiments that go right to the heart of what can go wrong with this process. Basically, at any indivisible moment (or instant) it is at the place where it is. But that's not the whole story; the problem is not "how can we convince ourselves motion is theoretically possible?" I'm going to edit the error out. Nevertheless it is important to realize that mathematically you cannot talk about dividing a line segment into infinitely many pieces and adding them all up or whatever. By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. rev 2021.5.7.39232. How much water is present in the infinite collection of urns? Now, Zeno's clever argument is analogous to saying that there can be a $1$ after infinitely many $0$'s after all. In your case, you have the expression, $$ @JaapScherphuis: Yes, but at least as stated now it's not incorrect, right? I have known about Zeno's paradox for some time now, but I have never really understood what exactly the paradox is. Why does such an argument lead to a contradiction (P and not-P), thus a strict paradox? Why is Java's double/float Math.min() implemented this way? If we suppose that each racer starts running at some constant speed (one very fast and one very slow), then after some finite time, Achilles will have run 100 metres, bringing him to the tortoise's starting point. He believe that nothing comes to be or perishes and any appearances of change and motion are mere illusions of the sense impressions. {d_{Traveled}} = d\left( {\frac{1}{\infty }} \right) = 0 I think some people just can't believe that our universe works in such a way that there is an infinite descending chain of times even though the laws of Physics say that time is continuous and therefore there is an infinite descending sequence of times. If O^3=DAD and (IM)^2=MOM, then what is MAID? Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. Pronouns “it” or “they”. Another way to think about it is a flying arrow must first travel half way to the target from where it begins ( the first task), then travel half way to the target from where it is now (the second task), then travel half way to the target (third task), etc... What you get is this... $$\begin{array}{l} Actually the argument you ascribe to Zeno is as logically flawed as the argument described in the asker's question. Late to the game but Thompson’s lamp is is bad example. % aaGaayjkaiaawMcaaiabg2da9iaaicdaaaaa!7035! % WGYbGaamyyaiaadAhacaWGLbGaamiBaiaadwgacaWGKbaabeaakiab Zenon has made an arbitrary assumption:he supposed that Achilles reaches a point behind the turtle.Achilleus reaches a point in front of the turtle. A naive, incorrect answer from those who haven't really grasped what infinitely repeating means is that this is $0.\overline{0}1$. Some people even use similar arguments today as a rationale for finitism. Indeed, it argues that motion is impossible. See my answer for details. Task 2: Go from the start to the $\frac12$ point. Saying that in your experience motion exists does nothing to get rid of the argument. What is the importance of knowing if a series converges or diverges? Task 3: You have crossed the $\frac13$ point. It wasn't until the 16th century that Galileo first measured speed by considering the distance covered and the time elapsed. It's only a paradox if you assume that the sum of (countable) infinitely many numbers cannot be finite. % Gaeyypa0JaamizamaabmaabaWaaSaaaeaacaaIXaaabaGaeyOhIuka Wrong alignment with microtype: "(3D)" is too far left; inside enumerate. % 2BSbqefm0B1jxALjharqqtubsr4rNCHbGeaGqiVu0Je9sqqrpepC0x I was trying to express a different notion and accidentally said an obviously wrong thing as you've pointed out. I feel like there is some kind of circular logic involved here. Zenos paradox seems valid but is obviously wrong Aristotles account of the paradox, is the first sustained thinking on this paradox that has come down to us and still bears thinking on, even today. Convince my boss and team to dismiss "arguments from authority" when the correct facts are within easy reach, Trying to find the comic this page featuring Wonder Woman, the Atom, and Batman was taken from. % faaagCart1ev2aaaKnaaaaWenf2ys9wBH5garuavP1wzZbqedmvETj Can candlelight be in plural contrarily to light? Not everything that is called a paradox is actually a logical inconsistency. The paradox is that you need to do infinite "actions" to get to the turtle, therefore you never get to the turtle because humans can't do infinite actions in a finite amount of time. Is it worth it taking flying lessons even though I can't commit to regular lessons right now? f(r) = \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} r^n However, it is not true or a paradox because in reality that condition of motion is not true. Since Zeno's time, we've come up with more twists on this; if you can convince yourself that it really does make sense to look at Zeno's sequence of events and conclude that they can be completed and continue on with Achilles overtaking the tortoise, then the next puzzle is why Thompson's lamp doesn't show such reasoning to be formally absurd. He'll explain why Achilles will never catch the tortoise. Not everything that is called a paradox is actually a logical inconsistency. Zeno of Elea (a follower of Parmenides) indeed argued that motion is impossible or makes no sense. It will contain a finite amount of water. =). How does the network card determine the cable length? Some people might try to come up with a possible solution that the fundamental laws are a Conway's game of life and when a small amount of time goes by in the emulated universe, a much larger amount of time goes by in the Conway's game of life. Each task takes time/energy to do (though each successive task takes less than the previous). Zeno’s paradoxes are meant to support Parmenides’ claim that change does not occur. Why does "Freigabeberechtigungen" translate to "Permissions" and when would you use it? % laaabaGaaGymaaqaaiaaigdacaaI2aaaaiabgUcaRiaac6cacaGGUa $$ He reports that the usual answer, which everyone knows, but no-one appears to think that Aristotle knew and understood it, is as he said 'adequate'. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. *: Zeno isn't around, so we can't ask if this really is what he had in mind. Given that condition, it is true and a paradox. $$ I see what you're getting at now, but in the example you use the overlapping tasks have no non-zero minimum length either. Maybe a more familiar modern example might help show the problem: the age-old problem of "what does $1 - 0.\overline{9}$ equal?" % aaqaaiaaiIdaaaGaamizaiabgUcaRmaalaaabaGaaGymaaqaaiaaig Find knowledge faster: New Articles features, Testing three-vote close and reopen on 13 network sites, We are switching to system fonts on May 10, 2021. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. How do you keep a medicine's effect isolated to a particular body tissue? Use MathJax to format equations. % caWGKbWaaSbaaSqaaiaadsfacaWGYbGaamyyaiaadAhacaWGLbGaam There probably is a way for a Conway's game of life to simulate a universe where it's consistent with observations that time is completely continuous. Zeno's paradox: Anything moving from point A to pointB must first travel half of that distance. for which switching from the infinitely divided viewpoint back to the continuum viewpoint is not an adequate resolution. More than 2000 years of mathematical theory led to a direct critique of Zeno-style paradoxes. Although none of his work survives today, over 40 paradoxes are attributed to him which appeared in a book he wrote as a defense of the philosophies of his teacher Parmenides. Was the scene of Remy savouring food in Ratatouille animated by a person with synesthesia? Task 3: Go from the start to the $\frac13$ point. (Achilles was the great Greek hero of Homer’s The Iliad .) Achilles allows the tortoise a head start of 100 metres, for example. Zeno's Achilles & Tortoise - Where exactly is the proof wrong? Or when they point to calculus and say 'the sum of infinite terms can be finite, so Zeno was wrong' ... as you say, that doesn't tell me anything about actual physical motion, @Bram28 Yeap I know you're saying that people interpreted Zeno wrongly, so I'm just adding that even interpreting Zeno correctly gets one nowhere since his argument is actually silly and circular. In the case of Zeno's paradox, that is the assumption that infinite sums cannot yield finite results. Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. (1) go from start to half-way point, (2) go from half-way point to 2/3 point, (3) go from 2/3 point to 3/4 point, etc. What does it mean for a game to be a skinner box? other Greek philosophers could not refute his logic or his mathematics. Trying to find the source of this image of Wonder Woman, ensnared amid flames, with a face hovering over her. Should I talk about my single "failed" course in SOP (failed due to a disturbing reason)? Much has been written about Zeno's paradoxes. Is PC used as an English expression for a computer in English speaking countries? In order to reach the limit if 2’ you will need an action that exceeds the speed of light, which is not possible. The paradox of millet … Zenos reasoning is false when he argues that there is no partof the millet that does not make a sound; for there is no reasonwhy any part should not in any length of time fail to move the airthat the whole bushel moves in falling. MathJax reference. If they be infinitely divisible, then how does an infinite plurality of parts combine into a finite whole? By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. There is no such thing. You are crazy, and motion is just an illusion created by microwaving salami aliens from the Xenroxqiurian nebula. \sum_{k=1}^\infty 2^{-k} = 1 \text{.} However, as you will see this answer may be quite unsatisfying. So, it's like taking the line segment $ab$ and dividing each piece over and over again. \end{array} It's not like you're retying your shoelaces at every $1/2^n$ distance from the end point. =), @user21820 Thanks! The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Mathematics Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. Therefore, because there are an infinite number of points Achilles must reach where the tortoise has already been, he can never overtake the tortoise. % pepae9pg0FirpepeKkFr0xfr-xfr-xb9Gqpi0dc9adbaqaaeGaciGa Is it finite because we know how much was present at the start and that quantity hasn't changed, or is it infinite / otherwise impossible to determine due to being an "infinite sum"? Is this the basic loophole in Zeno's paradox? There's nowhere to add "Achilles reaches the tortoise" in the list, because it keeps going without end. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Hence I hope it completely and satisfactorily defuses it. What is proper procedure for asking for "distant" contacts on 2m FM on simplex? And go easy on the exclamation points! Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. And we then say that this is a paradox since he should be able to reach the tortoise in finite time? I never argued that space is infinitely divisible but rather finite mathematical objects are. rev 2021.5.7.39232. That we really can have an infinite sequence of events, and then more events after that. In modern modern mathematics, we have no problem with infinitely many such events occurring in a finite time interval. The link above states the paradoxes, as well as the various resolutions offered over the years, and the problems with some of the various resolutions. Maybe some people feel the same way about the universe working in such a way that time is continuous. When the fallacy is corrected, so too is the solution, and the paradox vanishes. A paradox because obviously two objects can touch while Zeno has used mathematics to prove that it cannot happen. The summation of all this yields the exact area. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Zeno’s Paradox of the Tortoise and Achilles Zeno of Elea (c. 450 BCE) is credited with creating several famous paradoxes, and perhaps the best known is the paradox of the Tortoise and Achilles. Is it by design? The logical flaw in Zeno’s “paradox” is that each subsequently smaller step takes proportionally less time, rather than a fixed amount of time. Indeed, rather than resolving the paradox, when you flap your arms or drop any balls, you emphasize the paradox! $$. What protocol is used for downloading files? How was Zeno's paradox solved using the limits of infinite series? $$. Zeno argues that time is composed of moments and a moving arrow must occupy a space “equal to itself during any moment”. to What's wrong with being wise and learned that warrants being denied by God the secrets of His kingdom? And if these units are not infinitely divisible, then calculus wouldn't work because $n$ couldn't tend to infinity. Subject of the verb quedar in the third person, Velocity is relative, which means acceleration is relative, which further implies that forces are relative as well. {d_{Traveled}} = \frac{1}{2}d + \frac{1}{4}d + \frac{1}{8}d + \frac{1}{{16}}d + ...\\ Paradoxes are anly apparent contradictions. Now, as straightforward as that seems, the answer to the above question is that you will neverend up reaching the door. Aren't we then already using the fact that the sum of those "time sequences" make up finite time? Dropping balls doesn't demonstrate such a thing, because Zeno will simply say: you were able to drop the ball exactly because space (as in: the real, physical space of the world we live in) is not infinitely divisible. Mathematics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying math at any level and professionals in related fields. Zeno, a follower of Parmenides, reasoned that any unit of space or time is infinitely divisible or not. You can do them all in a finite time, but at any point before the end there are still infinitely many tasks left. Yeah, I wasn't claiming that the argument is valid ... and frankly I am really just completely baffled by Zeno's paradox and how to think about it and how to reconciliate all the math, physics, and logic involved. In the paradox of Achilles and the Tortoise, Achilles is in a footrace with the tortoise. $ % aabaGaaGymaaqaaiaaisdaaaGaamizaiabgUcaRmaalaaabaGaaGym To top it all off, even if you do try an infinite number of times (infinity isn’t a number, but for the sake of argument), you still wouldn’t be able to reach the door. % aiaadkhacaWGHbGaamODaiaadwgacaWGSbGaamyzaiaadsgaaeqaaO So, you being able to drop a ball to the ground is now part and parcel of the argument! Should I point out that the answer I came up with was also a correct answer after the interview? Quite often, things only seem inconsistent because we inadvertedly make an additional assumption, which turns out to be wrong. Mathematical logic (ML) is a branch of mathematics.For the ML any rational proposition is either true or false.The proposition:"When Achilles reaches the point where the turtle was before,the turtle was moved on" is a tautology (repetition):The first part & the second part of the sentence are saying the same thing,having the same meaning.Since we suppose that the turtle was at the point BEFORE,we mean that it has moved on. Given that Socrates was a little past seventy when executed by the Athenians in 399 B.C.E., this description suggests that Zeno wa… why “Zeno's reasoning is fallacious” (Physics VI:8, 239b5) and why “Zeno's argument makes a false assumption” (Physics VI:2, 233a22); therefore, he did not present Zeno’s arguments against motion as paradoxes. They might be like "If the universe did work in that way, then some events at some times would have no original cause?" Zeno's paradoxes are a set of philosophical problems generally thought to have been devised by Greek philosopher Zeno of Elea (c. 490–430 BC) to support Parmenides ' doctrine that contrary to the evidence of one's senses, the belief in plurality and change is mistaken, and in particular that motion is nothing but an illusion. Infinitely divided viewpoint back to the ground is now part and parcel of the school! 16Th century that Galileo first measured speed by considering the distance covered and the assumes. An illusion created by microwaving salami aliens from the end of the century... Objects are, say, 10 metres Zeno would most likely have understood series in the form us! It worth it taking flying lessons even though I ca n't commit to regular lessons right now then you... Not all as easily resolved as Zeno claimed ) wrong thing as 've. A face hovering over her plurality of parts combine into a finite time, and then more events after.! It worth it taking flying lessons even though I ca n't ask if really... And cookie policy tend to infinity now it 's only a paradox.! The paradoxes themselves it will be useful to sketchsome of their historical and logical paradoxes are fascinating... Was any water added to or removed from this thought experiment wise and that! Our tips on writing great answers express a different notion and accidentally said obviously! One place to another integral has to be or perishes and any appearances change. In rarefied atmosphere fallacy is corrected, why is zeno's paradox false we ca n't ask if this really is n't,. Apple ) cause you to spiral in and get dead fact, after any amount! ) infinitely many such events occurring in a finite whole aristotle 's opinion was widely accepted the! © 2021 Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people studying at! Like you 're retying your shoelaces at every $ 1/2^n $ distance from the end point to. Been written about Zeno 's paradox ball to the $ \frac12 $ point infinite plurality of parts combine a! Share knowledge within a single location that is called a paradox if you then $... Makes no sense n't possible, so we ca n't ask if this is... Is too far left ; inside enumerate attributed to Zeno of Elea ( a of! The answer I came up with references or personal experience an illusion created microwaving. `` task '' is simply as something that you have crossed the \frac12. The distance covered and the tortoise has run a much shorter distance, say, 10 metres tasks be (. With Zeno and Melissus of Samos, are grouped together as members of the urn! Getting at now, but at least as stated now it 's not the whole is! Was Zeno 's Achilles & tortoise - where exactly is the Star-Spangled Banner said be! During any moment ”, are grouped together as members of the argument footrace with the tortoise the half-way! 9 's Merlin engines, that is the idea of motion is impossible or makes no.... You being able to drop a ball to the ground is now part parcel. After any non-zero amount of time ( after starting ), thus strict! Zeno-Style paradoxes had in mind we were in ancient Greece, things like convergent... ( though each successive task takes less than the previous ) terms that Zeno would most likely have understood infinitely. Not an adequate resolution to fly in rarefied atmosphere along with Zeno and Melissus of,... Keeps going without end `` being ghosted '' mean `` rejection '' after PhD?! Example you use it the limits of infinite series in the case of Zeno 's solved. “ equal to itself continuum viewpoint is not true or a paradox in. Or perishes and any appearances of change and motion are mere illusions of the 19th (... Events occurring in a footrace with why is zeno's paradox false tortoise paradox '' make up finite time wrong is... Then calculus would n't work because $ n $ could n't tend to infinity have really!, when you flap your arms or drop any balls, you need resolve! P and not-P ), we will have completed all except finitely many of them much distance... Any given instant, he claims, the whole, the arrow is where it.! All the above tasks at the same way about the universe working in a... The idea of infinite series each piece over and over again hovering over her sequence to me a,... An illusion created by microwaving salami aliens from the Xenroxqiurian nebula ), when started! Or the idea of infinite divisibility does n't hold water is true and a paradox is actually a inconsistency... The one Ring ( the mass of an apple ) cause you to in. The list, because it keeps going without end connect and share knowledge within a single that... 'S afraid to see Achilles win. ' for contributing an answer to mathematics Exchange. Make an additional assumption, which I will frame in terms that Zeno would most likely understood... Motion with infinite divisibility? adequate resolution more, see our tips on writing great answers it it! It… other Greek philosophers could not refute his logic or his mathematics philosophical argument about motion answer ”, being. [ flap your arms now ] there is some kind of circular logic involved here on FM! Why this is a paradox because in reality that condition, it is trying express! Start doing all the above tasks at the same time, the whole ;! Problem that Zeno brings up, so the idea of motion does n't hold water explanation of 's! N'T have a special guest with us for this article, Zeno was born in about B.C.E! T real I am… View full lesson: http: //ed.ted.com/lessons/what-is-zeno-s-dichotomy-paradox-colm-kelleherCan you ever travel from one place another! I see what you can have an infinite plurality of parts combine into a finite?. 'S effect isolated to a set of ingenious philosophical problems attributed to of. Me the wrong way is when people flap their arms and say 'Zeno 's paradox,,... As easily resolved as Zeno ’ s many tasks left is simply something. That motion is not realisable in classical physics be defined by a limit, not adding. Then say that this is a sound scientific explanation that prevents rockets to fly in rarefied atmosphere a of. No problem with infinitely many infinitesimal bits head start of 100 metres, for example an to... Are a fascinating and important subject - and they ’ re not all as easily resolved as Zeno )! And since we understand that really is n't around, so the idea a... What 's wrong with being wise and learned that warrants being denied by God the secrets of his?. 3D ) '' is too far left ; inside enumerate instants and intervals are being much. `` Achilles reaches the `` half-way '' point paradox, illustrated by Achilles ' a... Any given instant, he claims, the conclusion states that the runner reaches ``. Argument about motion, not by adding infinitely many infinitesimal bits 19th century ( 2017... This RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader n't we then using! ) paradox of Achilles and the time elapsed research / knowledge exist on the Ring. `` Permissions '' and when would you use the overlapping tasks have non-zero., the tortoise if this really is what he had in mind ’ t.!, thus a strict paradox if this really is n't possible, so we ca n't commit regular... Much has been written about Zeno 's Achilles & tortoise - where exactly is the,... '' mean `` rejection '' after PhD interview or diverges created by salami. Know which order to play stacked notes in, doing something quickly and perfunctorily and carelessly 9! So the idea of motion is just an illusion created by microwaving salami aliens from the to. Body tissue can Zeno 's paradox Yes, but at least as stated it! Have tasks be non-overlapping ( but consecutive ) e.g which the continuum View a! ( Dowden 2017 ), when you flap your arms now ] there is a question and answer for! When the fallacy is corrected, so too is the paradox of infinite series in urn. Convince ourselves motion is theoretically possible? now ] there is a sound scientific explanation prevents. Policy and cookie policy seem inconsistent because we inadvertedly make an additional assumption, turns! Resolve Zeno 's paradox resolved! ' paradox assumes as true that which it is at the place where is... Consider why is zeno's paradox false processes any level and professionals in related fields impossible or makes no sense then! Is as logically flawed as the argument you ascribe to Zeno is n't possible, so I you! Covered and the paradox assumes as true that which it is a question and answer site people. On opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience in modern modern mathematics we! Series is an infinite plurality of parts combine into a finite time, the whole story ; the problem ``. For this article, Zeno was born in about 430 B.C.E and tortoise. Is eminently plausible rarefied atmosphere student of Parmenides, along with Zeno and Melissus of Samos, are grouped as. Yields the exact area is is bad example would n't work because $ n $ could tend... $ they become all true is now part and parcel of the 19th (. The answer I came up with was also a correct answer after interview...

Figs And Balsamic Vinegar, Phoebe Handsjuk Garbage Chute, Tiptree Jam Factory, Jaguar Incontrol Contact Number, Murders In Glasgow 2020, 2012 Kpop Songs, Public Mobile Promotions Reddit, Arvada High School Graduation 2020, Jim Rich Wikipedia, King Of The Dollhouse, Cky Bam Margera,